EB-1A Pro Tip: Membership in Associations Requiring Outstanding Achievement

In order to be eligible for classification as an EB-1A, a foreign national must establish that they possess a level of expertise in the sciences, arts, education, business or athletics, indicating that they are one of that small percentage who has risen to the very top of the field of endeavor.

This requires submission of evidence that they have sustained national or international acclaim and that their achievements have been recognized in the field of expertise. Such evidence includes a major, internationally recognized award, or at least three out of ten criteria.

For this post, we’re going to focus on documentation of the foreign national's membership in associations in the field, which require outstanding achievements of their members, as judged by recognized national or international experts in their disciplines or fields [8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(ii)].

I recently consulted with a foreign national and assessed his credentials for EB-1A classification. He firmly believed that he qualified for EB-1A classification based, in part, on his membership in two organizations in the engineering field. Unfortunately, after completing my assessment and reviewing these two organizations, I had to advise the foreign national that he did not meet this criterion. This was very unfortunate, because he paid thousands of dollars to join them based on the advice he received from an EB-1A coach (who is not an immigration attorney). Even before our consultation, he had already paid thousands of dollars to this EB-1A Coach and then followed her erroneous advice, which resulted in him losing significant money.

To be clear, in order to satisfy the memberships criterion: (1) the organization must require outstanding achievement as a prerequisite for a person to become a member; and (2) the person’s achievements must qualify as “outstanding” as judged by recognized national or international experts in the field of endeavor.

What does this mean? Professional organizations that simply require a person to pay a fee to join, without an assessment of the significance and quality of their contributions to the field, do not qualify as memberships in organizations that require outstanding achievement for EB-1A purposes. The USCIS Policy Manual is clear about this:

“Relevant factors that may lead to a conclusion that the person's membership in the association(s) was not based on outstanding achievements in the field include, but are not limited to, instances where the person's membership was based solely on the following factors (by themselves or in the aggregate):

• A level of education or years of experience in a particular field;

• The payment of a fee or by subscribing to an association's publications; and

• A requirement, compulsory or otherwise, for employment in certain occupations, as commonly seen with union membership or guild affiliation for actors.”

(Emphasis added)

Based on my assessment of the foreign national’s accomplishments, I was able to recommend two organizations for him to join that met the EB-1A criterion for memberships. After he joined, we were able to file a successful EB-1A petition on his behalf.

If you are thinking about petitioning for EB-1A classification, it is essential to work with a licensed business immigration attorney who possesses the immigration law knowledge and EB-1A experience.